Imagine what would happen if you suddenly couldn’t work anymore. Not that you lost a job or took a break. But that you were physically incapable of working. You’d have no money coming in. But you’d still have bills to pay.

And while it might seem far-fetched that would happen to you… it’s not. It happens much more often than you think. According to the Social Security Administration, 1 in 4 adults will become at least temporarily disabled before they reach retirement age. Those are not good odds.

You might be thinking those odds sound crazy. But you’re not considering what counts as a disability here. Disabling incidents include things like fractures and sprains, strokes, heart attacks, pneumonia, and pregnancy complications that can make it impossible to work. And that’s just a fraction of the list of injuries and illnesses that can sideline you for months.

During the time that you’re unable to work, disability insurance keeps the paychecks coming. Yes, they’re smaller than your regular pay, but they’re much better than no money coming in at all.

The Leading Causes of Disability Claims

Many people associate disability claims with job-related injuries. But those make up only a small percentage of claims. According to the Council for Disability Income Awareness (CDIA) the most common causes of disability insurance claims include:

Top short-term claims

  1. Pregnancy
  2. Musculoskeletal disorders (like lower back pain or joint pain)
  3. Injuries (like broken bones or sprains)
  4. Mental health issues
  5. Digestive problems

Top long-term claims

  1. Musculoskeletal disorders
  2. Cancer
  3. Injuries
  4. Mental health issues
  5. Cardiovascular problems (like heart attack or stroke)

Two Kinds of Disability Insurance

There are two main types of disability insurance: short-term and long-term. And as you’d expect, they cover different time periods.

Short-term disability insurance protects your income if you can’t work because of an illness or injury, and most policies include pregnancy as well. The policy replaces a portion of your income so that you can continue to pay your bills while you can’t work. Benefits usually replace 50% to 70% of your income for up to 12 months. That means your actual payouts depend on your how much you were making before the disability.

Long-term disability insurance (also called LTD) replaces pay if your earning ability is interrupted by illness or injury for extended periods of time. The payouts typically replace 50% to 60% of your base income. This insurance generally kicks in between 90 days and 6 months after your disabling event began. Then benefits can last for up to 10 years or until retirement age depending on the terms of your policy.

Both types of disability insurance may be provided by employers as part of an overall benefits package. If you don’t have access to these policies through your workplace, you may be able to buy them on your own.

Which Do You Need?

If you have access to disability insurance through your job, it almost always makes sense to get it. Even if your employer doesn’t chip in, you’ll still be getting the insurance at lower group rates than you could on your own.

When it comes to short-term disability insurance, whether you need it depends on your financial situation. If you have enough resources (like savings) to cover a three- or six-month absence from work, you can skip this insurance. Though, again, if it’s available through your workplace it often makes sense to get it anyway.

As for long-term disability, you don’t want to skip this one. If you can’t work for six months or more, you will need to have money coming in from somewhere. Going that long without income can drain your regular savings, retirement savings, and leave you with unmanageable debt. LTD can make all the difference for your financial security. So if you can afford the premiums – and there’s usually a lot of flexibility here – get this policy. Your best bet is to cover at least 65% of your current pay, so you have enough to live on until you’re back on your feet.

Woman in a wheelchair, walking with her daughter, confident knowing they have disability insurance to cover their needs.

Are Disability Benefits Taxable?

Like pretty much everything tax-related, whether or not you’ll have to pay taxes on your disability benefits depends on the situation.

  • If your employer pays the premiums, benefits are taxable.
  • If you use pre-tax dollars to pay the premiums through your job, benefits are taxable.
  • If you pay for the premiums with after-tax dollars – either through your employer or on your own – the benefits are not taxable.
  • If you and your employer split the premiums and your portion is with after-tax dollars, only a portion of the benefits will be taxable.

Bottom line: Don’t forget to consider whether your benefits will be taxable when you’re choosing the terms of your policy.

Own-Occupation vs Any-Occupation

Whether you qualify for benefits depends on how disability is defined in your LTD policy. There are two main definitions here: own-occupation and any-occupation.

Own-occupation disability means you can no longer work in your current specific field or specialty.

Any-occupation disability means you can’t work in any occupation that you’re technically qualified for. For example, if you’re currently a doctor and can’t provide medical care to patients anymore, you might still be able to work in a lab or teach or do medical billing.

Some LTD policies have a “switch” that turns on after 2 years (or other specified time period). That means it’s an own-occupation policy for the first 2 years but switches to an any-occupation policy after that.

How to Design Your Disability Insurance Policy

You have options when it comes to creating a custom disability insurance policy. The options you choose will affect your premiums, so you can design a policy that fits your budget and still provides a safety net.

Income replacement percentage

Your first decision involves how much income you need to replace to make ends meet. You need enough to pay your bills and live your life without completely emptying any savings or taking on excessive debt. Whether your benefits will be taxable comes into play here too. With non-taxable benefits, you can take a lower percentage of income and that means lower premiums.

Waiting period

All disability policies come with a waiting period (also called the elimination period), how long you have to wait from the start of your disability event until benefits start flowing in. The longer the waiting period, the lower the premium.

The typical waiting period for short-term disability benefits is 14 days, but it can be as long as 30 days or as short as 7.

The typical waiting period for long-term disability benefits is 90 days, but can be as long as 6 months.

Length of benefits

Up next: how long do you want your benefits to last. This is really more about long-term disability insurance, because the short-term version tops out at one year.

For LTD, you can go with either a fixed time period (called the term, usually at least 2 years), until retirement age, or until you’re able to work again. The longer the term, the higher the premiums.

Partial benefits

You can also get a policy that covers partial disability. A lot of times, a disabling event makes it impossible to work full-time but you still may be able to work reduced hours. That can also kick-in as your recovering an easing your way back to work. This allows for partial benefits to be paid in this circumstance.

Managing the premiums

Start by getting a quote for your ideal policy, then tinker with the parameters to match the premiums to your budget. Your first adjustment: increase the waiting period to reduce the premium.

Your second adjustment: shorten the payout period.

Your last adjustment: reduce the monthly benefit paid out.

Remember, when you can’t work, any money coming in for any period of time will be helpful for protecting your financial security.

Man on a respirator in a hospital bed who will be okay in the long run because he has disability insurance.

Ways to Ensure You Have the Financial Cushion to Survive a Disability

No one wants to plan for becoming disabled. However, as I mentioned at the top of this blog post, there is a 1 in 4 chance it may happen to you.

There are a couple ways to plan for this possibility. The first is to get disability insurance. The why and how are outlined in this blog post.

The second is to set up your personal and household budget to support paying for disability insurance, if you don’t get it through your employer, and to set up an emergency fund to support you should the worst ever happen. That way, you have a cushion to get you through those first few weeks or months, before the disability insurance kicks in.

My book, Budgeting 101, shows you how to streamline your finances, while ensuring you have everything you need to live comfortably. All while saving money that you can squirrel away in that emergency savings account.

If you become disabled at some point in the future, you have money to survive on. If not, you have a nice little nest egg you can use when needed to cover other things.

Find out more about Budgeting 101 and get your copy when you click on the button below.